Contents:
If the stock's market value falls below the strike price, there usually is no reason to use the option, since it would be cheaper to simply buy the stock on the open market than buy it with the option. Deciding when to exercise an option before it expires partly involves determining whether you think your company's stock will continue to increase in value, giving you an incentive to hold on to the option later. For tax purposes, stock options are divided into incentive stock options and non-qualified stock options.
Incentive options allow employees to wait to pay tax on the stock options until the employees sell the underlying stock and pay capital gains, rather than ordinary income tax on the proceeds, which usually means a lower tax bill. With non-qualified stock options, employees must pay ordinary income tax on the difference between the strike price and the market price on the date the option is exercised, even if the employees intend to hold on to the actual stock.
Steven Melendez is an independent journalist with a background in technology and business. Share It. Securities and Exchange Commission.
But the other piece of the puzzle is trying to grasp how taxes for employee stock options work. It could easily become a nightmare if you've never dealt with stock options before. Here are a few insights to take the confusion away so you can maximize the potential of this incredible work benefit. There are two main types of stock options that you could receive as part of your compensation gift: incentive stock options and nonqualified stock options.
The main difference between these two is how they are treated for tax purposes when you exercise the options. Incentive stock options ISOs , also known as statutory stock options, are granted under a stock purchase plan. However, nonqualified stock options NSOs are granted without a specific type of plan and are often referred to as nonstatutory stock options. When you have employee stock options, there are three special occasions you need to be aware of: the date your company granted you the options, when you exercised them, and how long you hold the shares you receive on exercise before you sell them.
These moments play an important role in your tax calculation. Most of the time, there is a vesting schedule tied to your employee stock options. Simply put, you cannot tap into your stock option benefits until you've been at your company for a certain period of time. After you are vested, then you can exercise the options at any time before they expire. Incentive stock options are simpler than nonqualified stock options from a tax perspective. Employees who have ISOs don't have to worry about taxes when they receive a stock option grant or exercise the options. The order of operations works like this: You receive a stock option grant and then you exercise the options when you are eligible and ready to do so.
After you exercise your options, then you'll have to make the ultimate decision: When do I sell my stock? Your other option: exercise your options in one period and sell your stocks later. If you are doing all this yourself, what is most important is that you pick a strategy that you feel And that doesn't make sense, since it means I would end up with a short-term loss. Is my thinking wrong? You're right in that the amount reported to you on your W-2 is the cost basis.
However, you should t Key concepts: restricted stock ; tax returns I did simultaneous cashless exercises of many vested stock options from ten grants that I received over the years. The exercise prices varied, and each grant had about 2, outstanding stock options about 20, stock options in total.
Do I need to report each of these sales separately on my Schedule D, or can I aggregate them in one line because I exercised and sold the stock on the same day? This is an interesting question that the IRS has not given specific guidance on. The amount of ordin Key concepts: tax returns ; exercise I am sitting here and trying to work out how to report my cashless nonqualified stock option exercise on my tax return. I cannot make sense of all the numbers, papers, and forms in front of me. My head is spinning and I am getting frustrated. Why do none of these numbers match?
The complex technical steps in a cashless exercise aside, essentially all the stock option shares ar Key concepts: tax returns ; exercise I will have substantial blocks of stock options to exercise in the years after my retirement. I expect no other income. Will the "wages" that result from these stock option exercises count against the Social Security retirement-income limits I am still below full retirement age , thus reducing Social Security benefits in the exercise year?
Would this stock option income alone qualify me to establish a Roth IRA as long as the income was below the Roth limits, of course?
The stock options granted while you were previously employed do not count against the Social Securit Key concepts: retirement ; retirement plans ; tax returns My company is going to restructure. It suggests that I move my family to our headquarters to keep my job or, more specifically, a position similar to mine that will be opened at our HQ. I have a number of stock options that are in the money but not vested. I wonder whether I can negotiate a buyout of those stock options if I choose not to move my family. Are there any legal issues with this? Not "legal issues," as in special rights you may have in unvested stock options assuming all employ Key concepts: job termination My company has offered to exchange underwater options for market-price options.
To avoid taking a hit in earnings, the company will wait six months and one day to make the exchange. If the company did not wait, how would I be affected?
Would I have ordinary income for the difference between the old and new option prices? There is no tax impact for you until you exercise the options. You do not pay tax on the exchange of Key concepts: underwater options I keep hearing about companies that are thinking about granting restricted stock instead of stock options.
If I think my company's stock price will do very well over the term of the option grant, it seems to me that I'm better off with stock options. I will get many more of them.
If the sales price is lower than the market value at the exercise date, you may use the difference between the lower sales price and the exercise price unless: It was a wash sale where you repurchased shares in the same company 30 days before or after you sold the shares. It can be lower or higher than that, depending on the type of option. Based on the provisions on tax avoidance, the share acquisition cost can also be regarded as undeductible when the employer company trades back and forth in its own shares to turn the amount paid for the shares deductible Gov. There are many examples of employees at startups, like Instagram, who became millionaires overnight from their stock options alone. But it usually boils down to do you….
Why do companies grant fewer restricted stock shares than options when the options seem more valuable? If I normally would get 10, options, why would I get maybe 3, or 4, shares of restricted stock? Is my thinking backward, or has my memory of underwater options faded too quickly? Your thinking shows that you like the upside potential of options over the "safety" of restricted st They believe I underreported a gain on a sale of stock, which was in fact a cashless exercise of my NQSOs.
I did not include the transaction on Schedule D because I knew the amount of the gain was already included as ordinary income on my W However, the IRS sees the proceeds from the broker for the transaction and do not see anything on my Schedule D. I know that I have paid tax on the transaction.
But should I have included the sale on my Schedule D with the proceeds equal to the cost, with no gain or loss reported? Whenever you have a sale of stock you need to complete Schedule D. Your tax basis for the NQSOs He died in Is this the correct way to do this? When you exercised the option, it triggered ordinary income to you.
The employer correctly reported But what is the tax treatment if his estate or beneficiary never exercises them?
Exercising underwater options makes no sense, so I let the options expire. When options are exercised, generally the estate or beneficiary is able to take an income tax deduct I expect the stock price to return to these levels eventually. Are there any strategies or mistakes to avoid in a market upturn? When the stock market rebounds after a fall, one of the most common mistakes among optionholders is Key concepts: financial planning I learned of your site three days too late, I'm afraid.
I exercised ISOs that have been vested for more than two years. Do you have any creative suggestions? You needed to hold the stock one year after exercise to obtain beneficial long-term capital-gains ta My company requires employees to exercise options within 60 days of termination. I am also restricted by a blackout period and have insider knowledge of financial results that will be announced in the next few months.
If I left the company next week, could I exercise my 22, options? I have a limited time to exercise but am restricted from exercising because of the blackout period and my inside information. The exercise itself would not be insider trading, so you may exercise and hold the stock.
The sale o Key concepts: insider trading ; job termination I have always found the taxation of ISOs confusing. I still own the company stock. Through ignorance I did not report the ISO exercise-and-hold on my tax return for that year or complete the form to determine whether I owe any AMT which I now learn is likely. What are the consequences? Generally, if you find a tax-return error, and the statute of limitations period has not yet ended, I have about 9, vested options.
Friends at other companies have faced similar situations, and the post-termination exercise periods for their options were extended beyond the day period in their plan. Are companies required to do this? When your company ends your employment, the vesting clock will stop, and post-termination exerci Key concepts: job termination My company is selling the small division I work for to focus on its core business and make its balance sheet less confusing to investors.
I will no longer work for the company but will still have the same job, with new corporate owners of my division. I have 17, options, about half of which are now vested. What will happen to them? Check your stock plan to see if it addresses this type of divestiture in which just a small division Do blackout or lockdown periods exist for stock plans as well? Some in the media have confused "blackout" with "lockdown.
Thus, on But I am baffled by the tax rules on my sale of the stock when I hold the shares after the purchase but not long enough to qualify for special tax treatment. You did not hold the ESPP stock two years from the date of grant and one year from purchase. So you I plan to hold the stock after exercise. If after one year I sell the stock so that it results in a long-term capital gain, how will I recover the difference between what I already paid in taxes and what I will then owe? The exercise and the later sale are two separate transactions. What you really are asking is: "If I The tuition bills arrive five times a year, with the first payment due in late September.
I want to set up a program with my company and broker in which I automatically exercise enough options and sell the stock to pay each tuition bill as it's received, using the net proceeds. Could this prearranged selling plan violate insider-trading laws and my company's blackout rules?
You are in luck. SEC Rule 10b now provides a safe-harbor defense from insider-trading liability f Generally, state taxes are an itemized deduction on your federal tax return, along with other well-k Key concepts: exercise ; tax returns My company has gone through two rounds of layoffs. Fortunately, I still have my job and in-the-money stock options.
However, my company has suggested very strongly that I take an extra two weeks of summer vacation, unpaid.